It was suggested of me to try several root beer brands and do a side by side comparison. If anyone hasn't noticed there are a LOT of brands of root beer on the market so this is going to be a two part review and comparison. For this first part I'll be comparing Mug, Barqs, A&W, and the generic root beer sold by Wal*Mart. Each of these will be judged based on four criteria. The first being headiness, or the ability to form a frothy head when poured into a cup. The second is scent, strength and pleasantness of aroma. Third is fizziness, the amount of fizz per sip. Finally and most importantly is taste, because obviously if it has a good head, smells good, and is fizzy but tastes like a mud puddle, then I'd recommend a differing brand. I've also some criteria in selecting these brands to keep it fair. I have chosen only brands which I can purchase in a plastic bottle, which I have poured into identical plastic cups, in the event packaging can affect any of the above criteria. I'm not going to do any type of arbitrary points system, I'll just declare a winner and second place in each category, then name the root beer I felt supreme. Now, lets get started.
Headiness:
Definitive Winner: Mug. The Mug root beer immediately formed a head in the cup and maintained the full amount for several minutes before no major froth was visible on top.
Second Place: Generic Wal*Mart brand. I was actually caught off guard by this, the generic root beer held up quite well and had the head not dissolved much faster than the Mug, this would have been a much closer category.
Scent:
Definitive Winner: A&W. A&W's scent was strong, but pleasant, almost warm and welcoming.
Second Place: Mug. Mug was by far the strongest smelling of the brands. Unfortunately I found the aroma to be pungent, and not too pleasant on my poor nostrils.
Fizziness:
Definitive Winner: Barqs. Barqs was by far the fizziest of the root beers as the bubbles were immediately noticeable in the cup as well as on my tongue when I took a sip.
Second Place: This was a much more difficult choice than the previous category but I must again go with the generic. While Mug had the most bubbles by viewing it in the cup but seemed almost flat when sipped. A&W had the opposite problem as no bubbles were noticeable in the cup but had a fizzier feel on my tongue. The generic brand was much fizzier on the tongue with a fair amount of noticeable bubbles on the cup.
Taste:
Definitive Winner: A&W. A&W was very flavorful while still being wonderfully smooth for a root beer.
Second Place: Barqs. Barqs definitely has bite, it's the strongest by far and isn't the easiest to drink down, but if that's your thing, then go for it.
Overall:
Definitive Winner: Generic brand. Shockingly, this root beer very nearly scored in the top two in each category, and when it wasn't number one or number two, it gave them both a good run for the money. In taste it's a milder brew, with a very smooth finish. It has a solid amount of head and overall fizz without overwhelming you, and while the scent is pleasant it is not a very strong aroma and you really have to try to find it.
Second Place: A&W. The grand-daddy has definitely had a sweet ride and easily the best overall flavor, but aesthetically you don't get the expected head or fizz in the cup, with a decent amount of fizz when you drink it.
Part 2 will come out Thursday with a few more brands, plus a review of long term storage!